Washington
(December 13) – As
part of an ongoing investigation into the financial collapse of Enron
Corporation, House Energy and Commerce Committee Chairman Billy Tauzin (R-LA)
and Oversight and Investigations Subcommittee Chairman James Greenwood (R-PA)
today called on Andersen LLP – Enron’s outside auditor – to turn over
records from Enron audits and provide Committee staff interviews with Andersen
personnel, specifically David
Duncan, the partner-in-charge of the Enron account.
Additionally, in a letter
sent Tuesday to Jeffrey Skilling, Tauzin and Greenwood requested that the former
Enron Chief Executive Officer (CEO) make himself available for Committee
staff interviews.
(Below are copies of the
letters sent to Andersen Managing Partner and CEO Joseph F. Berardino
and Former Enron CEO Jeffrey Skilling.)
December
13, 2001
Joseph
F. Berardino
Managing Partner and Chief Executive Officer
Andersen LLP
33 W. Monroe Street
Chicago, Illinois 60603
Dear
Mr. Berardino:
This
letter is to confirm requests for certain Andersen records and interviews with
Andersen personnel made during a meeting last week between Committee staff and
Andersen representatives. Specifically,
Committee staff requested the opportunity to interview David Duncan, the
Andersen partner-in-charge of the Enron account, and those Andersen employees
who worked on the audits of the Enron Corporation from 1997 to present.
Please make Mr. Duncan available for a Committee staff interview no later
than December 21, 2001. Additionally,
the Committee staff made requests for various Andersen records and information
as they related to the Enron audits.
As
part of the Committee’s investigation, and pursuant to Rules X and XI of the
U.S. House of Representatives, please provide the Committee with the following
records by December 21, 2001:
1.
All work papers and records for the years 1997 to 2001 in
Andersen’s possession or control
relating to the Enron account, including, but not limited to:
a.
all records relating to proposed adjustments by Andersen, and/or
Enron’s internal auditors, accounting staff, or financial officers that were
not recorded in Enron’s financial statements from 1997 to present; and
b.
all correspondence issued
by Andersen to Enron management or the Audit and Compliance Committee relating
to Andersen’s audits or reviews of Enron’s 1997 to 2001 financial
statements, and all records and correspondence relating to Enron’s internal
accounting practices and controls from 1997 to present;
2.
All records in Andersen’s possession or control relating to Enron’s
decision announced in November 2001 to restate its financial statements for the
years 1997 to the present;
3.
All records relating to Andersen’s recommendation(s) to Enron to
restate its financial statements for the years 1997 to the present;
4.
A specific accounting of
Enron’s off balance sheet debt from 1997 to 2001, including obligees and
amounts owed;
5.
All records in Andersen’s possession or control relating to any
consultations with or opinions rendered by Andersen’s Professional Standards
Group relating to any or all of Enron’s Special
Purpose Entities (SPE),
partnerships, subsidiaries, or affiliates;
6.
All records in
Andersen’s possession or control
relating to the formation or structuring of Enron’s various SPEs,
subsidiaries, and/or partnerships, to include but not limited to, all
partnership agreements and their management policies, and past or present
organization structures;
7.
All records in
Andersen’s possession or control relating to any contacts, notifications or
approvals of the LJM Cayman, L.P. ("LJM1"), LJM2 Co-Investment, L.P.
("LJM2"), Joint Energy Development Investments, L.P.
("JEDI"), Chewco Investments, L.P. ("Chewco"), the Raptor
entities, the Marlin Water Trust (“Marlin”), Osprey Trust (“Osprey”),
Whitewing Associates, L.P. (“Whitewing”) and Big Doe partnerships, and/or
their subsidiaries, partners, or affiliates, and their transactions with Enron,
including but not limited to, by Enron's Board of Directors, Enron's Officers,
Enron's Audit and Compliance Committee, and/or Andersen;
8.
All records in Andersen’s possession or control disclosing or
indicating that Enron employees or officers held equity interests or positions
in any or all Enron SPEs, partnerships, subsidiaries, or affiliates.
9.
All records in
Andersen’s possession or control reflecting any objections or concerns
expressed by any Andersen employee or partner, or any Enron employee, officer or
Director relating to any equity interest in or position held by any Enron
employee or officer in LJM1,
LJM2, JEDI, Chewco, the Raptor
entities, Marlin, Osprey, or the
Whitewing and Big Doe partnerships, or any Enron SPE, subsidiary, affiliate, or
partnership;
10.
All correspondence in
Andersen’s possession or control
exchanged between Enron and Andersen regarding the structure of, disclosure of,
and/or accounting for LJM1,
LJM2, JEDI, Chewco, the Raptor entities, Marlin, Osprey, and/or the Whitewing
and Big Doe partnerships or their subsidiaries, or
any Enron SPE, affiliate, subsidiary, or partnership disclosed in any of
Enron’s filings with the Securities and Exchange Commission, including but not
limited to all Enron management representation letters relating to said SPEs and
partnerships to its auditors from 1997 to present;
11.
All records in
Andersen’s possession or control
relating to Enron’s Audit and Compliance Committee meetings, and copies of all
Andersen presentations made to the Audit and Compliance Committee from 1997 to
present;
12.
All management letters issued by Andersen to Enron from 1997 to present,
and all records relating to such management letters.
Also, copies of any correspondence between Andersen and Enron regarding
the adequacy of Enron’s internal auditing or accounting controls from 1997 to
present;
13.
All records relating to any non-audit, consulting services provided by
Andersen to Enron for the period 1997 to the present;
14.
A list of any current or
former Andersen executives, management level managers, and/or accounting and
finance personnel who left Andersen to work for Enron from 1997 to present;
15.
All records relating to any memoranda or correspondence between
Andersen’s engagement team or Andersen’s Houston office and Andersen’s
national office discussing the impact on the Andersen’s independence from
providing non-audit consulting services provided to Enron from 1997 to present;
16.
All records relating to the Andersen audit engagement team’s final
memorandum summarizing any sensitive accounting, disclosure and/or auditing
issues and the conclusions reached by the engagement team with respect to those
matters;
17.
All records in
Andersen’s possession or control
relating to peer review reports issued to Andersen from 1997 to the present, and
copies of any draft reports or letters of comments provided to Andersen, the
Public Oversight Board, and AICPA staff or peer review committee during the
current peer review being performed by Deloitte & Touche; and
18.
List of the names of the
following lead engagement personnel on the Enron engagement and the period they
have been assigned to the Enron engagement:
a.
Audit partner
b.
Review or concurring partner (s)
c.
Manager(s)
d.
Lead Senior Accountant
e.
Lead Tax Partner
f.
Senior relationship or service partner if someone other than (a) above.
g.
Partners in the U.S. Professional Services Group, Industry specialist
partners, and the lead consulting partner(s) assigned to service Enron.
19.
All records in
Andersen’s possession or control relating to all Enron SPEs, including but not
limited to LJM1, LJM2 JEDI, Chewco, the Raptor entities, Marlin, Osprey, and the
Whitewing and Big Doe partnerships, and/or their subsidiaries, partners, or
affiliates, not produced in response to the above requests.
Please
note that, for the purpose of responding to this request, the term
"Enron," as used above, means Enron Corp., or one or more of its
divisions, subsidiaries or affiliates, or related entities.
The terms "records" and "relating" should be
interpreted in accordance with the attachment to this letter.
If
you have any questions, please contact Mr. Mark Paoletta, Chief Counsel for
Oversight and Investigations, at (202) 225-2927.
Thank
you for your prompt attention to these matters. We appreciate your cooperation.
Sincerely,
W.J.
“Billy” Tauzin, Chairman
James
C. Greenwood, Chairman
Subcommittee on Oversight and Investigations
cc:
The Honorable John D. Dingell, Ranking Member
The
Honorable Peter Deutsch, Ranking Member
Subcommittee on Oversight and Investigations
December
11, 2001
Mr.
Jeffrey Skilling
c/o Bruce A. Hiler, Esq.
O’Melveny & Myers, LLP
555 13th Street, N.W.
Suite 500 West
Washington, D.C. 20004-1109
Dear
Mr. Skilling:
The
Committee on Energy and Commerce has initiated an investigation into the issues
surrounding Enron Corporation’s collapse, as well as any potential
implications it may have on the U.S. electricity and natural gas markets.
To assist us in this inquiry, we request that you make yourself available
for a Committee staff interview within the next two weeks, or no later than
December 21, 2001. If you are unable to travel to Washington, D.C., Committee
staff is willing to travel to Houston, Texas, or another specified location.
To
schedule this interview, or if you have any questions, please contact Mr. Mark
Paoletta, Chief Counsel for Oversight and Investigations, at (202) 225-2927.
Sincerely,
W.J.
“Billy” Tauzin, Chairman
James
C. Greenwood, Chairman
Subcommittee on Oversight and Investigations
cc:
The Honorable John D. Dingell, Ranking Member
The
Honorable Peter Deutsch, Ranking Member
Subcommittee
on Oversight and Investigations